One of my favourite features of Flickr is the option to license images under Creative Commons licenses. (Basically these are less-restrictive versions of a normal copyright). I do this because I want to let other people use my images in their own projects.
Today I got a message from another Flickr user asking permission to use my image on a collaborative news site called NowPublic. This is great! She also sent me a link to a form where I could approve the sharing of my image. I thought this was odd, because I had already licensed the image under Creative Commons. They are free to grab it and use it anyway. So I checked out their link, and apparently they have a system where you can’t share images unless you sign up for an account on their site. I’m not interested in having an account on NowPublic, but I’d love for them to use my images.
So I wrote back and told her that she’s free to use my image, but I wasn’t interested in signing up. But it turns out that NowPublic is designed in such a way that images are automatically attributed to the person who shares them. So if she were to download my image from Flickr and share it on NowPublic, it would automatically be attributed to her. This strikes me as poor design. If I distribute my image with a Creative Commons license, I don’t want to sign up for an account each time somebody wants to use it. As long as they follow the terms of the license, they should be free to use it without my involvement.
NowPublic is cheating themselves out of a great resource by requiring artists to jump through hoops like this. A collaborative site should be designed to work with Creative Commons licenses, not introduce artificial roadblocks. I hope they manage to work around this problem, because the idea behind their site is quite promising!